Joy & Vitality Centre peppermint and spearmint herbs displayed with two cups of mint tea, dried leaves and fresh mint sprigs.

Peppermint vs Spearmint: Why These Two Mints Taste So Different

Peppermint and spearmint look similar, belong to the same plant family and are both used in herbal teas. Yet the moment you smell them side by side, the difference becomes obvious.

Peppermint has a strong, cool, penetrating aroma. Spearmint is usually sweeter, softer and more familiar from chewing gum, mint sweets and refreshing summer drinks.

Why do two closely related plants smell so different? The answer comes down to their natural aromatic compounds, especially menthol and carvone.

At Joy & Vitality Centre in Calgary, we enjoy helping customers understand the botanicals behind their favourite teas. This guide explores the differences between peppermint and spearmint, how to brew them and when to choose each one.

What Is Peppermint?

Peppermint, Mentha × piperita, is a hybrid mint traditionally associated with watermint and spearmint.

It belongs to the Lamiaceae family, which also includes rosemary, thyme, basil and lavender.

Peppermint leaves have a powerful aroma and a distinctive cooling sensation.

That sensation is largely associated with menthol, one of the important compounds in peppermint's essential oil.

Peppermint is commonly enjoyed as a hot herbal infusion, especially after meals or when someone wants a strongly minty, caffeine-free drink.

What Is Spearmint?

Spearmint, Mentha spicata, is another member of the mint family.

It is widely used in culinary preparations, including mint sauces, salads, fruit drinks, desserts and herbal teas.

Compared with peppermint, spearmint generally has a softer and sweeter-smelling character.

Its aroma is strongly associated with carvone, particularly the form known as (R)-carvone.

Although spearmint can still taste fresh and minty, it usually creates less of the intense cooling sensation associated with menthol-rich peppermint.

Menthol vs Carvone: Why the Two Mints Smell Different

The most fascinating difference between peppermint and spearmint is found in their essential oil composition.

Peppermint commonly contains substantial amounts of menthol and menthone, while spearmint is often rich in carvone and limonene.

These compounds interact differently with our senses.

Menthol and the Cooling Sensation

Menthol activates a temperature-sensitive receptor called TRPM8, which is involved in detecting cool sensations.

That is why peppermint can make your mouth feel cool even when the tea itself isn't cold.

The sensation is real, but it doesn't mean peppermint has physically lowered the temperature of your mouth.

Carvone and Spearmint's Sweet Aroma

Carvone contributes a characteristic sweet, herbal, minty aroma to spearmint.

It does not produce the same strong menthol-like cooling impression.

This makes spearmint especially appealing in recipes where you want mint flavour without an overpowering icy sensation.

Natural mint plants contain many other aromatic compounds, and their exact proportions vary with cultivar, growing conditions and processing.

Peppermint vs Spearmint: Quick Comparison

Feature Peppermint Spearmint
Botanical name Mentha × piperita Mentha spicata
Plant family Lamiaceae Lamiaceae
Typical aroma Strong, sharp, cooling Sweet, gentle, herbal
Notable aroma compounds Menthol and menthone Carvone and limonene
Cooling sensation Usually pronounced Usually milder
Caffeine Naturally caffeine-free Naturally caffeine-free
Common culinary uses Herbal tea, chocolate, mint blends Iced tea, salads, sauces, fruit drinks

Which Mint Is Better for Herbal Tea?

Neither is universally better. They simply create different experiences.

Peppermint is a good choice if you enjoy a strong, refreshing aroma and a noticeable cooling sensation.

Spearmint may be more appealing if you prefer a gentler, sweeter mint flavour.

For people who find peppermint too intense, spearmint can be a pleasant alternative.

You can also blend them together to create a balanced cup that combines peppermint's freshness with spearmint's softer character.

Does Peppermint Tea Help Digestion?

Peppermint has a long history of traditional use after meals, and its aroma is often associated with digestive teas.

Researchers have studied certain peppermint preparations, particularly enteric-coated peppermint oil capsules, for digestive symptoms.

However, findings involving concentrated peppermint oil capsules should not be applied automatically to ordinary peppermint tea.

The preparation, concentration and dose are different.

Some people with acid reflux or heartburn may find that peppermint aggravates their symptoms. Individual tolerance matters.

Enjoy peppermint tea for its flavour and traditional culinary use without treating it as a replacement for medical care.

What About Spearmint and Hormones?

Spearmint has attracted attention because a small number of human studies have investigated spearmint tea and certain hormone-related measurements.

These studies are interesting, but the evidence remains limited and does not establish spearmint tea as a proven treatment for hormonal disorders.

Results from small studies cannot guarantee the same outcome for every person or every retail tea product.

Anyone managing a hormonal or endocrine condition should seek individualized advice from a qualified healthcare professional rather than relying on herbal tea alone.

How to Brew Peppermint Tea

Peppermint leaves release their aroma readily into hot water.

For a general loose-leaf preparation, start with approximately 1 teaspoon of dried peppermint leaves per 250 mL of hot water.

Cover the cup while steeping for approximately 5–10 minutes, or follow the directions on your particular product.

Covering the cup helps retain some of the volatile aromatic compounds that contribute to peppermint's fragrance.

Strain and enjoy warm.

If the tea tastes too strong, use fewer leaves or shorten the steeping time.

How to Brew Spearmint Tea

Spearmint can be prepared in much the same way.

Start with approximately 1 teaspoon of dried spearmint leaves per 250 mL of hot water.

Cover and steep for approximately 5–10 minutes, adjusting to taste and following the product label.

The finished tea will generally be less intensely cooling than peppermint and may have a sweeter herbal aroma.

Both mints are naturally caffeine-free when prepared as pure herbal infusions.

Can You Mix Peppermint and Spearmint?

Yes. The two mints can work beautifully together in culinary herbal blends.

A simple starting ratio is one part peppermint to two parts spearmint for a softer mint tea.

If you enjoy stronger cooling notes, try equal amounts.

You can also combine mint with lemon balm, chamomile or suitable fruit ingredients, depending on the flavour you want.

Keep the first batch small so you can adjust the balance before making a larger blend.

Recipe 1: Double Mint Herbal Tea

This simple recipe brings out the differences between peppermint and spearmint while allowing them to complement each other.

Ingredients — 2 Servings

  • 1 teaspoon dried peppermint leaves
  • 2 teaspoons dried spearmint leaves
  • 500 mL hot water
  • 1 thin slice of lemon, optional
  • Honey, optional

Instructions

  1. Place the peppermint and spearmint leaves in a teapot or suitable infuser.
  2. Pour the hot water over the herbs.
  3. Cover and steep for approximately 5–8 minutes.
  4. Strain into two cups.
  5. Add lemon or a little honey if desired.

For a stronger peppermint flavour, increase the peppermint slightly in your next batch.

Recipe 2: Citrus Spearmint Iced Tea

Spearmint's gentle, sweet aroma works especially well with citrus and chilled drinks.

Ingredients — 4 Servings

  • 4 teaspoons dried spearmint leaves
  • 750 mL hot water
  • 250 mL cold water
  • 1 orange, thinly sliced
  • 1 tablespoon fresh lemon juice
  • Ice cubes
  • Maple syrup, optional

Instructions

  1. Place the dried spearmint in a heatproof jug or teapot.
  2. Add the hot water, cover and steep for approximately 8 minutes.
  3. Strain out the leaves.
  4. Add the cold water and allow the tea to cool.
  5. Refrigerate until chilled.
  6. Stir in the lemon juice and add the orange slices.
  7. Serve over ice and sweeten lightly if desired.

The result is a refreshing, naturally caffeine-free drink with a gentler mint flavour than a strongly brewed peppermint infusion.

Five More Ways to Use Mint in the Kitchen

1. Add Spearmint to Fruit Salad

Fresh spearmint pairs beautifully with watermelon, strawberries, citrus and other fruits.

2. Pair Peppermint With Chocolate

Peppermint's strong cooling aroma creates a familiar contrast with rich chocolate flavours.

3. Make a Mint Ice Cube

Freeze a few clean fresh mint leaves in water for a decorative addition to cold drinks.

4. Blend Mint With Lemon Balm

For a softer herbal infusion, experiment with mint and lemon balm in a small test batch.

5. Create Your Own Herbal Tea Blend

Use peppermint for a stronger cooling character or spearmint for a gentler mint note. Adjust the proportions to suit your taste.

How to Store Dried Mint Leaves

Dried mint leaves contain aromatic compounds that can gradually fade with exposure to air, heat and light.

Store them in a tightly closed container in a cool, dry cupboard away from direct sunlight.

Keep the leaves away from moisture and strong-smelling ingredients.

When you open a fresh package, the aroma should be recognizable. If the leaves have very little fragrance, they may no longer produce the flavour you expect.

Are Peppermint and Spearmint Suitable for Everyone?

Both herbs are widely used in food and tea, but individual sensitivities and medical circumstances still matter.

Peppermint can worsen reflux symptoms in some people. Anyone with an allergy to mint-family plants should avoid the relevant ingredients.

Concentrated mint essential oils are not equivalent to ordinary herbal tea and should never be substituted into a recipe without appropriate food-use directions.

If you're pregnant, breastfeeding, taking medication or managing a medical condition, consult a qualified healthcare professional before using concentrated herbal preparations.

Discover Mint Teas at Joy & Vitality Centre

At Joy & Vitality Centre, we carry a wide selection of herbs and functional teas for customers who enjoy exploring different botanical flavours.

Our Sleep Well Herbal Tea Blend includes both peppermint and spearmint alongside other herbs, offering another example of how different mint varieties can be combined.

Explore our Single Herbs & Superfoods collection or visit us at Unit 154, 9919 Fairmount Drive SE, Calgary, Alberta.

Whether you prefer peppermint's bold cooling sensation or spearmint's sweeter, gentler aroma, understanding what makes them different can help you create a better cup of tea.

And sometimes the most interesting botanical discoveries begin with two familiar herbs that turn out to be surprisingly different.

Back to blog